Mystery & Thriller Bestsellers

Agatha Christie's 'And Then There Were None' is cited as the all-time bestseller in this genre, so it might be regarded as unnecessary, if not impertinent, to apply our Mystery & Thriller Score. So we will respect the popular vote.

How it might be seen against current literary fashion is another matter.

For the following reviews of new and recent titles, and 'satisfaction assessments' in ever-popular mystery & thriller novels, we have used four characteristics defining the genre, along with brief explanations of how each contributes to a compelling reading experience.

1. Suspense & Pacing

This characteristic measures how effectively the author builds and maintains tension throughout the narrative.

A high score (8-10) indicates a book that keeps you on the edge of your seat, with a relentless and well-timed flow of events that makes it difficult to put down.

A lower score (1-3) suggests a slow, meandering plot that fails to create a sense of urgency.

Pacing is the speed at which the story unfolds, while suspense is the feeling of anxiety or excitement about what may happen.

2. Plot & Twist

This quality assesses the intricacy of the storyline and the effectiveness of its surprising revelations.

A high score (8-10) is awarded to novels with a cleverly constructed plot, featuring a truly shocking and well-integrated twist that re-frames the entire narrative.

A low score (1-3) reflects a predictable plot with obvious or poorly executed plot twists that feel contrived or unearned.

The twist should be logical in hindsight, not just a random event.

3. Character & Motive

This characteristic evaluates the depth and believability of the characters, particularly the protagonist and the antagonist, and the clarity of their motivations.

A high score (8-10) is given to books with complex, relatable, or intriguing characters whose actions are driven by understandable and well-developed motives.

A lower score (1-3) points to one-dimensional characters with flimsy or nonsensical reasons for their actions.

The character's psychology should feel authentic and contribute to the overall suspense.

4. Atmosphere & Setting

This quality measures how well the author uses the environment to enhance the mood of the story.

A high score (8-10) indicates a novel where the atmosphere (the emotional tone) and setting (the time and place) are palpable, effectively creating a sense of dread, claustrophobia, or mystery.

The location itself can feel like a character in the story.

A low score (1-3) suggests a generic or underdeveloped setting that does little to support the narrative's emotional impact.

Current new and bestselling Mystery & Thrillers

(How they measure up against our 'Quality Score')

The Teacher: A Psychological Thriller

Suspense & Pacing: 9/10

The book is a masterclass in tension. The pace is rapid and unrelenting, with short, cliff-hanger style chapters that make it nearly impossible to put down. It's a true page-turner where the suspense builds with every page, keeping the reader on edge.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is well-constructed, with multiple layers of deception and a satisfying, jaw-dropping twist in the final act. While some readers may see it coming, the reveal is cleverly executed and re-contextualizes the entire story in a surprising way.

**Character & Motive: 7/10

The main characters are complex and unreliable, with shifting allegiances and hidden pasts. Their motivations are initially murky, but they become clearer as the plot progresses. The psychological depth of the characters is what drives the story, making the reader question their own judgment.

Atmosphere & Setting: 7/10

The atmosphere is tense and claustrophobic, largely confined to the school and a few key locations. The sense of unease is palpable, reflecting the psychological games being played. The setting of a high school adds to the feeling of dread, as the author subverts the typical innocence of the environment.

Overall Score: 8/10

Review:

Freida McFadden's The Teacher is a riveting psychological thriller that delivers on its promises of suspense and surprise.

The novel's strength lies in its relentless pacing and an unputdownable narrative that keeps you guessing until the very end.

McFadden expertly manipulates the reader's perception, crafting a story where no one is who they seem and every reveal is a punch to the gut. While some might find the characters' actions extreme, the book is a perfect example of a fast-paced thriller that prioritizes a wild ride over deep character studies.

This is a must-read for fans of psychological thrillers who enjoy a complex plot with a satisfying, shocking conclusion.

Nothing to See Here: (Cristy Ward thriller) y Susan Lewis

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The novel starts as a slow burn, taking its time to establish the characters and the cold case at its centre. While the initial pace may feel a bit sluggish to some readers, it builds steadily, culminating in a fast-paced, gripping second half. The use of a podcast format adds a unique element, with each episode release building suspense and revealing new clues.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is intricate and well-layered, with plenty of red herrings and twists that will keep you guessing. The central mystery of the Kellon Manse murders is compelling, and the final reveal is both surprising and satisfying. Susan Lewis masterfully weaves together past and present to deliver a shocking and logical conclusion.

Character & Motive: 7/10

The protagonist, true-crime podcaster Cristy Ward, is a relatable and determined character. Her personal life, including her complicated relationship with her ex-husband, adds an emotional layer to the story. While there are a number of supporting characters, which can feel a bit overwhelming, their motivations are generally well-defined and contribute to the overall complexity of the mystery.

Atmosphere & Setting: 6/10

The atmosphere is one of slow-building dread and psychological tension, but it's not the primary focus of the book. The setting is more of a backdrop for the characters' personal and professional lives. However, the use of a true-crime podcast as a narrative device creates a modern and compelling mood that will resonate with fans of the genre.

Overall Score: 7/10

Review:

Susan Lewis's Nothing to See Here is a compelling and deeply emotional thriller that puts a modern spin on the cold-case mystery.

The book's strength lies in its meticulously crafted plot and the unique use of a true-crime podcast as the vehicle for investigation.

While the first half of the book is a slow burn, the narrative pays off in the second half with a series of twists and turns that will keep readers on their toes.

Cristy Ward is a well-drawn protagonist whose personal struggles add a layer of depth to the mystery.

This is a great choice for readers who enjoy character-driven mysteries and a satisfying, shocking twist at the end.

The Skeleton Road: A chilling, nail-biting Karen Pirie thriller by Val McDermid

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The pacing is more of a gradual ascent than a frantic sprint. Val McDermid takes her time to build the case, intertwining the present-day cold case with a historical narrative from the Balkan Wars. While this may feel slow for readers expecting a non-stop thrill ride, the methodical unwinding of the mystery creates a deep and satisfying sense of suspense.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

This is where the novel truly shines. The plot is complex, expertly weaving together two seemingly unrelated storylines. The central mystery is compelling, and the final twist is not only shocking but also deeply rooted in the characters' backstories and the historical events that shape them. It's a testament to McDermid's skill as a plotter.

Character & Motive: 8/10

Detective Chief Inspector Karen Pirie is a strong, intelligent, and a refreshingly real protagonist. Her dedication to cold cases is palpable, and her personal life adds a layer of depth to her professional pursuits. The other characters, particularly the academic with a hidden past, are also well-drawn, with clear and believable motivations that drive the narrative forward.

Atmosphere & Setting: 7/10

The atmosphere is a key element, moving between the gritty, gothic landscape of Edinburgh and the sun-drenched but war-scarred backdrop of Croatia. The author successfully uses the contrast between these settings to heighten the tension, with the historical sections being particularly atmospheric and haunting. The setting itself becomes a character, steeped in history and secrets.

Overall Score: 7.5/10

Review:

Val McDermid's The Skeleton Road is a masterful and intelligent police procedural that delves into the long-lasting consequences of war.

This novel is a slow-burn mystery, meticulously constructed with a rich, detailed plot that will reward patient readers. McDermid's deep dive into the historical backdrop of the Balkan Wars is both enlightening and integral to the central cold case.

DCI Karen Pirie is a compelling and authentic protagonist, and her investigation is a brilliant exercise in piecing together a complex puzzle.

While it may not have the breakneck pace of a pure thriller, the psychological depth and a truly stunning plot twist make it an unforgettable and rewarding read for any fan of serious crime fiction.

The Black Loch: an explosive return to the Hebrides and the internationally bestselling Lewis Thrillers by Peter May

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The pacing is deliberate, unfolding like a slow-burn investigation rather than a frantic race. Peter May expertly builds a sense of dread as he peels back the layers of a decades-old mystery.

The narrative shifts between the present-day murder inquiry and flashbacks to a tragic event in Fin Macleod's youth, which may not satisfy readers looking for a fast-paced thriller, but it creates a deep, lingering tension.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is intricately woven, connecting a modern-day murder to a dark secret from the past.

May masterfully uses red herrings and buried clues to keep the reader guessing. The final twist is well-earned and emotionally impactful, providing a satisfying and a logical conclusion to the complex puzzle.

Character & Motive: 8/10

The novel's strength lies in its profound character work.

Fin Macleod is a deeply flawed and compelling protagonist, driven by a father's love and haunted by his past.

The motives of the key characters are complex and believable, stemming from long-held secrets and the harsh realities of life on the remote island. You can feel the weight of their history in every interaction.

Atmosphere & Setting: 9/10

The remote, rugged landscape of the Isle of Lewis is a central character in itself.

May's descriptions are incredibly vivid, capturing the brooding, windswept beauty of the Hebrides. The atmospheric setting enhances the chilling tone of the story, creating a palpable sense of isolation and foreboding.

The island's history and harsh environment permeate the entire narrative, making it a truly immersive experience.

Overall Score: 8/10

Review:

*Peter May's The Black Loch is a masterful work of crime fiction that is as much about place and character as it is about a murder.

The novel is a welcome return to the Hebrides for fans of the Lewis Trilogy, offering a rich and emotionally resonant story.

May's prose is as exquisite as ever, painting a stunning picture of the island and its inhabitants. The slow-burn pacing may test the patience of some, but it allows for a deeply satisfying exploration of character and motive.

The past and present are seamlessly intertwined, culminating in a powerful and unexpected resolution.

For those who appreciate a meticulously plotted mystery with a strong sense of place and profound emotional depth, The Black Loch is a must-read. *

The Boyfriend: A Psychological Thriller by Freida McFadden

Suspense & Pacing: 9/10

Freida McFadden is a master of pacing, and The Boyfriend is no exception.

The narrative is driven by a constant, almost frantic energy, with short, punchy chapters that end on cliff-hangers, compelling you to read "just one more." This book is an absolute page-turner that builds tension relentlessly from the first page.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is well-structured with a dual-timeline narrative that expertly misdirects the reader.

Just when you think you've solved the mystery, McFadden pulls the rug out from under you with a final, shocking twist that is both clever and completely unexpected. While some of the setups may require a bit of a suspension of disbelief, the payoff is well worth it.

Character & Motive: 6/10

The protagonist, Sydney, is written to be a bit naive and makes questionable decisions, which can be frustrating for some readers. Her motivations are clear—she wants to find love—but her actions can feel contrived at times to serve the plot.

The antagonist's motives are revealed in a compelling way, but the characters' overall depth is secondary to the high-octane plot.

Atmosphere & Setting: 7/10

The novel effectively uses its modern-day setting of New York City and the world of online dating to create a sense of unease and vulnerability.

The atmosphere is one of claustrophobic paranoia and psychological manipulation, where the fear doesn't come from a dark and stormy night but from the potential danger lurking in plain sight, on your phone screen, or right next door.

Overall Score: 7.5/10

Review:

Freida McFadden's The Boyfriend is a rollercoaster of a psychological thriller that will keep you guessing until the very last page.

It’s a fast-paced, high-stakes story that preys on the modern anxieties of online dating and the search for "the one."

While the main character's choices may sometimes strain credulity, they serve to heighten the suspense and create an unputdownable reading experience.

The novel's greatest strengths are its relentless pacing and a truly jaw-dropping twist that is vintage McFadden. For fans who enjoy a wild ride with plenty of shocking reveals and a book that’s impossible to put down, The Boyfriend is a must-read.

A Litter of Bones: A Scottish Crime Thriller (DCI Logan Crime Thrillers Book 1) by JD Kirk

Suspense & Pacing: 8/10

The novel starts with a powerful hook and maintains a relentless pace.

The story is a ticking clock thriller, where the suspense is consistently heightened by the race to save a missing child.

The chapters are short and the plot is well-driven, making it a genuine page-turner that's hard to put down.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is cleverly constructed, with a central question that keeps the reader guessing: did DCI Logan catch the wrong man a decade ago?

J.D. Kirk expertly layers clues and red herrings, leading to a shocking and well-earned final twist that re-contextualizes everything that came before. The reveal feels both surprising and inevitable in hindsight.

Character & Motive: 8/10

DCI Jack Logan is a deeply compelling and well-developed protagonist. He's a haunted, cynical, but dedicated detective driven by a past failure, which gives his investigation a personal and emotional weight.

The supporting characters are also well-drawn, and their motives are clear and believable, adding depth to the narrative.

Atmosphere & Setting: 8/10

*The Scottish Highlands are more than just a backdrop; they are a character in themselves. The author's vivid descriptions create a tangible sense of place, from the rugged, beautiful scenery to the claustrophobic feeling of a small, isolated community.

This atmospheric setting enhances the dark and chilling tone of the story. *

Overall Score: 8/10

Review:

J.D. Kirk's debut, A Litter of Bones, is a powerful and gripping crime thriller that announces a formidable new voice in Scottish fiction.

The novel's greatest strength lies in its unrelenting tension and a masterful plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat.

DCI Jack Logan is a memorable protagonist, a flawed but brilliant detective whose personal demons add a rich layer of complexity to his high-stakes investigation. The author expertly uses the haunting beauty of the Scottish Highlands to create a palpable sense of dread and isolation.

With its sharp dialogue, shocking twists, and a relentless pace, this book is a must-read for fans of gritty, character-driven mysteries.

Sister: The phenomenal Sunday Times and New York Times bestseller by Rosamund Lupton

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The novel is more of a psychological mystery than a fast-paced thriller.

The suspense is built through the unravelling of a complex family tragedy rather than through a series of action sequences.

The pacing is a slow, methodical burn, allowing the reader to become fully immersed in the narrator's emotional state. This isn't a book to race through, but rather one to savour for its emotional depth and growing tension.

Plot & Twist: 9/10

The plot is ingeniously constructed, framed as a letter from the protagonist, Beatrice, to her deceased sister, Tess.

It's a non-linear narrative that keeps the reader off-balance. The story is a masterclass in misdirection, with multiple suspects and red herrings.

The final, shocking twist is a genuine "did-not-see-that-coming" moment that redefines the entire narrative and makes you want to re-read the book from the beginning to find the hidden clues.

Character & Motive: 9/10

The novel's strength is its deep exploration of the bond between sisters.

The characters are incredibly well-developed and emotionally complex. Beatrice's grief, guilt, and fierce love for her sister are palpable, and her journey of discovery is as much about learning who Tess was as it is about confronting her own limitations.

The motivations of the characters, from the police to the family, are all rooted in believable psychology, making for a compelling and emotional read.

Atmosphere & Setting: 7/10

The setting of London, with its parks and urban backdrops, is used to create an atmosphere of quiet dread and a sense of being haunted by a loss.

The psychological atmosphere is particularly strong, focusing on the mind of a woman in denial and grief. It’s a chilling and sombre mood that permeates the narrative, rather than a physically terrifying setting.

Overall Score: 8/10

Review:

Rosamund Lupton's Sister is a powerful and poignant psychological thriller that defies easy genre classification.

It is a mystery driven by love, grief, and the unbreakable bond between siblings. The novel's brilliance lies in its unique narrative structure and a plot that keeps the reader guessing until the final, breath-taking pages.

While the pacing is more deliberate than a typical thriller, it allows for a rich and emotional exploration of its characters. Beatrice is an unforgettable protagonist whose journey to uncover the truth about her sister’s death is both heart-breaking and gripping.

This is a must-read for anyone who loves a well-crafted mystery with a devastatingly effective twist, and an emotional core that will stay with you long after you've finished the book.

The Dilemma: An emotional and dark family drama thriller by B A Paris

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The suspense is built around a powerful emotional conflict, rather than a traditional crime.

The pacing is deliberate, unfolding over a single day. The author slowly ratchets up the tension, creating a sense of dread as the two main characters, Adam and Livia, keep critical secrets from each other.

While it lacks the breakneck speed of a typical thriller, the emotional stakes keep you engaged.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is constructed as a dual narrative, with Adam and Livia each telling their story of a terrible event that happened on the same day.

This structure is highly effective, as the reader knows a terrible secret is being held by both of them. The "twist" is less about a single shocking reveal and more about the heart-breaking convergence of two separate, life-altering events, which is both clever and devastating.

Character & Motive: 9/10

The emotional core of this novel is its greatest strength.

The characters are deeply human, relatable, and flawed. Their motivations—driven by love, fear, and a desire to protect their family—are incredibly believable.

The author excels at exploring the moral complexities of the choices they make. You feel their anguish and are forced to question what you would do in their situation.

Atmosphere & Setting: 6/10

The atmosphere is one of overwhelming emotional tension and familial unease.

The setting, a suburban home on the day of a 40th birthday party, is used to heighten the contrast between the celebratory mood and the personal tragedies unfolding behind closed doors.

The tension is psychological and interpersonal, rather than physical or environmental.

Overall Score: 7.5/10

Review:

B.A. Paris’s The Dilemma is a gripping and profoundly emotional psychological thriller that is more a domestic drama than a typical whodunit.

The novel’s brilliance lies in its unique narrative structure, which expertly builds tension by revealing two separate, devastating secrets simultaneously.

The book is less about a crime and more about the moral choices we make when faced with unimaginable tragedy. The characters are deeply empathetic, and their heart-breaking predicament makes for a compelling and unforgettable read.

While it lacks the breakneck pacing of a traditional thriller, the slow-burning suspense and the deeply human story make it an excellent choice for fans of dark and emotional family dramas.

The Impossible Fortune: (The Thursday Murder Club) by Richard Osman

Suspense & Pacing: 7/10

The pacing is less a heart-pounding sprint and more of a leisurely stroll with a sharp mind at work.

The suspense is not created by imminent danger, but by the intellectual puzzle of the case.

The narrative moves at a comfortable, witty clip, punctuated by delightful banter and clever investigative manoeuvres, making it an engaging and relaxing read rather than a tense one.

Plot & Twist: 8/10

The plot is a delightfully complex and intricate puzzle, with a series of twists and mis-directions that are as charming as they are clever.

Osman expertly weaves together multiple storylines and red herrings, leading to a satisfyingly convoluted climax. The twists are not shocking in a dark, macabre way, but rather in a "oh, of course!" kind of way, which is perfectly suited to the tone of the series.

Character & Motive: 9/10

This is where the book truly excels.

The core cast of septuagenarian sleuths—Elizabeth, Joyce, Ron, and Ibrahim—are some of the most charming, hilarious, and well-developed characters in modern crime fiction. Their motivations are a mix of boredom, a desire for justice, and a pure love of the game.

Each character's unique skills and backstory are fully utilized, making their interactions and detective work a joy to read.

Atmosphere & Setting: 8/10

The atmosphere is one of cosy comfort and intellectual curiosity.

The setting of Coopers Chase, a retirement village, is meticulously crafted and serves as a delightful backdrop for the murders and mysteries.

The mood is light-hearted and witty, a refreshing contrast to the often dark and gritty nature of the genre. It's a setting that invites you to pull up a chair and join the investigation with a cup of tea.

Overall Score: 8/10

Review:

Richard Osman’s The Impossible Fortune is a triumphant return to the world of Coopers Chase and a brilliant example of a cosy mystery done right.

The novel foregoes gritty suspense for intellectual puzzles, witty banter, and the undeniable charm of its elderly protagonists.

The plot is a clever web of clues and mis-direction that will keep readers happily guessing until the very end. The real heart of the book, however, lies in its characters—Elizabeth, Joyce, Ron, and Ibrahim — whose camaraderie and sharp minds make solving a murder seem like the most delightful of pastimes.

If you're looking for a crime novel that is less about fear and more about fun, intelligence, and companionship, then this is the perfect book for you.